Using Magnets to Relieve PainThere are many different products on the market which claim to reduce pain via the use of magnets. Some of my clients claim that products such as magnetic collars have helped their pet. I have been wondering if there was any evidence for their therapeutic use. Recently I have been looking into the evidence available regarding the efficacy of these products. Unfortunately such evidence seems to be in short supply at the moment. That does not necessarily mean that these products do not work; it is more likely to suggest inadequate funding for this type of research.
It is claimed that magnetic therapy has been used for thousands of years by ancient Greek, Egyptian and Chinese civilisations. It is possible to obtain a wide range of products designed for animals which claim to use magnets to improve mobility and decrease pain in arthritic animals. Some products are claimed to treat a wide range of conditions. Products available include collars and blankets for small animals and boots or rugs for horses.
Magnets are supposed to work by subjecting the cells to an external magnetic field which improves circulation, maintains the body's optimal pH and maintains electrical conductivity in the cells. All this, it is claimed, increases the body's ability to heal itself. That the magnetic field would have an effect of some kind on cells is not unlikely because so many molecules within the cell are electrically charged. Just how this effect works and why it helps healing and pain relief is something which requires further investigation. Perhaps it may work a little bit like a TENS machine which is certainly very effective at relieving pain? It is also unclear what type and strength of magnet should be used with different companies seeming to promote different types of magnet.
I have no idea why these products should work but there is plenty of anecdotal evidence to suggest that they do!
There is some published scientific evidence which suggests the effects of magnetic therapies in patients with pain from musculoskeletal problems were positive. For example a study published in the BMJ suggested that there was a decrease in osteoarthritic pain in human patients wearing magnetic bracelets compared with those who did not. (It was unclear whether this response was due to the placebo effect of wearing a bracelet or not.) (Harlow et al; 2004)
My own view on the use of magnetic collars and similar products is that they are worth a try. I would recommend them mostly for animals with osteoarthritic pain or some other musculoskeletal pain such as sprains or strains. If they do work they would certainly be safer and cheaper than steroidal or non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. If they don't work for your pet then they are unlikely to do any harm.
Reference:
Harlow, Greaves, White, Brown, Hart and Ernst: Randomised controlled trial of magnetic bracelets for relieving pain in osteoarthritis of the hip and knee. BMJ 2004;329 : 1450 - 1454 © Samantha Coe. All rights reserved. Further information, news and pet-related healthcare articles are available at vetbase.co.uk
Questions Answered
|
colitis (dog) (31-May-07 06:40PM)
Ruth asks:
Is it acceptable to give milk products like yogurt and cheese for dog with occasional colitis or would it cause a bout of colitis ? I would discontinue when colitis ... view
|
|
Constipation (cat) (25-Feb-07 06:59PM)
Joyce asks:
Snowy has had problems for quite a while. He seems to be constantly having problems with his bowel movements. It may take him several attempts, over maybe half an hour of ... view
|
|
Lous keeps biting and chewing on her inner legs (dog) (02-May-07 02:22PM)
Terri asks:
Can I put Benadryl cream on her legs for the itch? ... view
|
|
cod liver oil supplements (dog) (26-Jan-07 07:45PM)
Karen asks:
My 8 year old labrador gets very stiff jointed after excercise. I give her a cod liver oil tablet daily. Is this ok and what doseage should I give her ... view
|
|
Wounds come up on head; round and blood red (cat) (01-Feb-07 06:40PM)
Charlene asks:
My cat has come up with round blood patches on his head; what are they? He is on antibiotics for a virus is this connected? ... view
|
|
Upset tummy maybe or poison (dog) (01-Oct-07 08:43PM)
 Danny asks:
Hi there
Last week I found Lewy in our garden hacking up (not sick), just the noise. After checking his throat both internally ( as far as I could go), and feeling ... view
|
|
cruciate ligament (dog) (02-Jun-07 04:15PM)
Alex asks:
How do I know my dog's cruciate ligament is getting better after the op? Four months later he is still limping on and off and seems to be in pain. ... view
|
|
Blood in dog's stools (dog) (31-Oct-07 08:53AM)
Lee asks:
Hi. We recently got a 3 year old Labrador from a friend. From what we can see she has a little weight problem as she was not walked regularly which we ... view
|
|
Eye Problem (cat) (18-Sep-07 05:04PM)
 Jamie asks:
I put a flea collar on my cat and after that I noticed her eye is pink/reddish and she either holds it half closed or all the way closed. I was ... view
|
|
wobbly hind legs (dog) (29-May-07 02:38PM)
Ruth asks:
7 lb. Shi Tzu, 5 years old, otherwise healthy, is refusing to walk (but will go outside for short periods). I can see her wrist and elbow joints wobbling when ... view
|
|
broken paw (dog) (03-Oct-07 04:21AM)
Rachel asks:
Spike jumped off the bed and when he landed his paw went under him. He started howling, we were able to calm him and straighten the leg. We splinted it and ... view
|
|
Chewing paws (dog) (09-Feb-07 08:59PM)
Pauline asks:
My springer has started chewing the skin from his pads, to the extent that they are red raw and he cannot walk.
I am trying to watch him but cannot always catch ... view
|
|
severe diarrhoea for past 8 hours (dog) (29-Jan-07 01:55PM)
Peter asks:
Diarrhoea and vomiting started in the middle of last night.
Sickness has stopped but diarrhoea continuing.
Treatment please? ... view
|
|
Itching (dog) (27-Sep-07 02:00AM)
 Marie asks:
Jasper has itching on his lower back above the base of his tail. He has a large scab about 4 inches in diameter but he doesn't have fleas. What causes this ... view
|
|
coat condition (dog) (09-Feb-07 04:32PM)
Melody asks:
Ozzy seems to be losing more and more of his hair, the area under his chin on the neck is pink and hairless. It does not irritate him because he rarely ... view
|
|
Floppy tail (dog) (05-Feb-07 08:21PM)
Jason asks:
Bingo's tail is normally straight and constantly wagging but today it is between his legs and very droopy. Apart from this he is himself do you know the possible reason for ... view
|
|
Non union of bone in cat (cat) (09-Feb-07 02:05PM)
Deb asks:
I would like to enquire, by way of a second opinion, on best treatment for my cat's non-union of bone in his back leg (2 metatarsals). Our vet has mentioned ... view
|
|
upset stomach (dog) (30-Jan-07 02:09PM)
Karen asks:
My dog's poo is runny most of the time. We keep him on the same food. We have only had him since October last year. We took him on as a ... view
|
|
diagnosed with a torn cruciate ligament (dog) (03-May-07 03:53PM)
Douglas asks:
Henry has been diagnosed with a torn cruciate ligament on a hind leg. He is 17 years old and our vet is not keen on any operation and said plenty of ... view
|
|
Fleas and skin problem (na) (26-Oct-07 01:26AM)
Joanne asks:
I have two cats, a neutered tom and his sister. They are 6 and a half yrs. old. They have never been outdoors. A few days ago I was ... view
|
|
|  |
Your Questions Answered
|
Injured Wild Owl 30-Nov-07
Kelly asks:
I found an owl this morning, very small but adult. It flew into a power line. It's still alive. ... view
|
|
swollen hind leg 20-Nov-07
 Zshai asks:
I have a 6-day-old bunny who has a swollen hind leg. I saw her mama step on her but ... view
|
|
Sick syrian hamster 08-Nov-07
Sara asks:
Hi. My syrian hamster is 2 and half yrs. old. The last 24 hrs I have noticed a big ... view
|
|
lack of sleep 07-Nov-07
Bill asks:
We have a 14 month old Yorkshire terrier, which goes to bed at around 6.30pm, because I have MS ... view
|
|
wet tail 06-Nov-07
Evelyn asks:
Can a young hamster be successfully treated for wet tail and what would it roughly cost? ... view
|
|
Alfie 06-Nov-07
Elaine asks:
Hi Sam
Thank you. Alfie has no feeding time he just has food in his bowl when he wants it ... view
|
|
Guarding problem 05-Nov-07
 Elaine asks:
Alfie is a terrible guarder and will take your hand off if you try and retrieve an object he ... view
|
|
White Gums and Dark Stool 02-Nov-07
Leslie asks:
My 8 week old American Bulldog has really white gums, around the eyes is also white. She has dark ... view
|
|
Dog's Health 01-Nov-07
William asks:
My dog is around 11 years old, possibly older (we received her as she was taken from a bad ... view
|
|
behaviour 31-Oct-07
Debby asks:
Hi Max is very lively of course but he seems to get very excited and bites the children, not ... view
|
|
Blood in dog's stools 31-Oct-07
Lee asks:
Hi. We recently got a 3 year old Labrador from a friend. From what we can see she has ... view
|
|
upset stomach 30-Oct-07
kat asks:
About three days ago my dog started acting like she was sick; diarrhoea and vomiting along with excessive sneezing ... view
|
|
Blood in Poo 28-Oct-07
Mandy asks:
Treacle is now 9 wks old and had her first vaccination two days ago. I have noticed that at ... view
|
|
neutering 27-Oct-07
 ashen1956 asks:
3 days ago Molly-Mae gave birth to 5 kittens. How long should I wait before having her neutered and ... view
|
|
Ordering Insulin Online 26-Oct-07
Purdie asks:
Purdie is diabetic and I'm keen to find a way of reducing the cost of the treatment. Currently ... view
|
|
Fleas and skin problem 26-Oct-07
Joanne asks:
I have two cats, a neutered tom and his sister. They are 6 and a half yrs. old. They ... view
|
|
My cat has a hole in its stomach! 23-Oct-07
Sarah asks:
My cat has a hole the size of a dime in its stomach. He doesn't seem to be ... view
|
|
labrador vomiting bile and nearly passing out 22-Oct-07
Paul asks:
Hi there - our five year old male labrador is generally in very good health - excellent appetite, plenty ... view
|
|
Guinea pig fits 22-Oct-07
Renate asks:
My guinea pig is acting strange. I've only had him around a week and he's running as if spooked ... view
|
|
feeding 22-Oct-07
Terry asks:
Is it safe to feed my GSD raw chicken wings, he is 16 months old and is 37 kg? ... view
|
|
|
